Remember how bagels used to taste?

That’s what you’ll taste today in every bite at Bagel Jay’s. It’s the consistently delicious deli favorites that you’ve been missing.

It’s fresh-baked bagels, signature tuna fish, and homemade cream cheese shmears, the way they’re supposed to be.

Bagel Jay's is back and proud to serve the finest mouth-watering bagels, finest dark roasted coffees, deli sandwiches, soups, salads, and more.

Specializing in Family Events! Breakfasts, lunches and brunches for weddings, Bar and Bat Mitzvahs, funerals and other special occasions.

Fresh Bagel & Coffee in Buffalo NY

Catering Bagels Wraps and Shmears

Bagel Jay’s does Corporate Catering for groups from 10 to 500!

  • Pickup and Dropoff Services Available
  • Full service available
  • Breakfast, Brunches and Lunches
  • Deli Sandwich Platters
  • Salads
  • Beverages
  • Desserts
  • Business referrals
  • Gift certificates

Drug reps welcome

Reviews & Testimonials

Our Specialty Bagels & Wraps

At Bagel Jay's we've perfected the craft of delicious specialty bagels, wraps and shmears for over 15 years,
so we invite you to take a look at some of the mouth watering menu items available at our 3 locations.

Bagel Jay’s started the fresh bagel tradition in Buffalo, NY in 1976. Perfect for a quick bite to meet family, friends or business associates. Breakfast or Lunch. Specializing in homemade cream cheese shmears, dark roasted coffee, NY style bagels & bagel sandwiches, fresh deli sandwiches, soups, classic salads and desserts. Dine in an upscale casual & relaxed atmosphere or take out. Perfect for catered corporate gatherings & special occasions. Don’t miss the’s the best ever!