Buffalo's Favorite Bagels.
From the first bite you'll understand why Bagel Jay's award winning bagels have been Western New York's favorite since 1976.
Fresh-baked bagels, deli classics, signature tuna fish, and homemade cream cheese shmears - the way they’re supposed to be.
The Tastiest Catering
Bring Bagel Jay's home - or to work! We specialize in family and corporate events. Whether it's a birthday or a board meeting - breakfast, lunch or brunch, we proudly offer catering options for groups of 10 up to 500.