Gift Certificate Redemption

Bagel Jays is now closed due to our sale to Brugger’s Bagels. If you have an outstanding gift card, please scan the QR code or click the button below and follow the steps to get a refund.

Buffalo’s Favorite Bagels.

From the first bite you’ll understand why Bagel Jay’s award winning bagels have been Western New York’s favorite since 1976.

Fresh-baked bagels, deli classics, signature tuna fish, and homemade cream cheese shmears – the way they’re supposed to be.

Enjoy our Specialty Bagels & Wraps

At Bagel Jay’s we’ve perfected the craft of delicious specialty bagels, wraps and shmears.

We invite you to take a look at some of the mouth watering menu items available at our 3 locations.

The Tastiest Catering

Bring Bagel Jay’s home – or to work! We specialize in family and corporate events. Whether it’s a birthday or a board meeting – breakfast, lunch or brunch, we proudly offer catering options for groups of 10 up to 500. 

Made in Buffalo.

Bagel Jay’s began our fresh bagel tradition in Buffalo, NY. Since 1976 we have been a part of the community, and we’re dedicated to continue investing in its future. We support Buffalo’s independent local businesses by buying local.


Think local, buy local, be local. Buy Buffalo First!