Browse our Menu
Buffalo’s Best Bagels Since ’76
Pick up a bagel, Jay’s secret recipe — New York style, hearth baked fresh throughout the day!
Our shmears are made with the freshest cream cheese available. You’ll find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries and smoked salmon.
Our deli sandwiches are made on your choice of bagel, wheat wrap, NY rye, asiago, wheatberry bread or focaccia with your choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts.
Buy the Pound!
Pick up a pound of our Classic Salads – tuna, chicken, egg, whitefish, nova lox – or a flavored Shmear or two!
Surprise them with Bagel Jay’s Gift Cards!
Surprise your clients and friends with Bagel Jay’s Gift Certificates, available at any of our locations in $5 increments.
Pickup & Delivery Available!
Oven Fresh
The way they’re supposed to be!
Jay’s secret recipe – New York style, hearth baked fresh throughout the day!
Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Onion, Garlic, Everything, Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry, Pumpernickel, Tomato Pesto, Vegetable, Whole Wheat, Multi-grain, Chocolate Chip, Cranberry Orange, Marble-Rye, Jalapeno Cheddar, Salt, Baily, Bagel Sticks
| Single Bagel | $1.60 |
| 1/2 Dozen | $8.49 |
| Baker’s Dozen | $15.99 |
| Sack of Bagels & More – Baker’s Dozen w/tub of butter and tub of shmear | $20.99 |
| Cinnamon Stick | $2.09 |
| Asiago | $2.19 |
| Muffin | $2.99 |
| Pastry Heart | $3.29 |
| Cinnamon Twist | $3.29 |
| Oatmeal | $2.19 |
* Nominal charge for bagel slicing
Shmears
It doesn’t come any better than this!
Our spreads are made with the freshest cream cheese available. You’ll find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries and smoked salmon.
| On a Bagel | Tub | |
| Plain, Plain Lite | $3.49 | $3.69 |
| Flavored Shmear | $4.09 | $5.09 |
| Lox Shmear | $4.79 | $5.79 |
Veggie, Veggie Lite, Scallion, Strawberry, Cinnamon Honey, Red Pepper Jalapeno, Garlic & Herb, Olive & Pimento
| Bagel w/Jelly | $2.39 |
| Bagel w/Butter or Smart Balance | $2.69 |
| Bagel w/PB & J | $3.69 |
| Muffin w/Butter | $4.59 |
| Breakfast Special – available all day – Bagel with a Plain or Reduced Fat Shmear and a dark roast 12 0z. coffee | $5.79 |
Eggel Bagels
Farm fresh favorites – all day long!
| No. 1 Egg & Cheese | $3.99 |
| No. 2 Egg, Ham & Cheese | $4.99 |
| No 3. Egg, Bacon & Cheese | $4.99 |
| No. 4 Egg, Chicken Sausage & Cheese | $4.99 |
Jay’s Classics
| Tuna Salad | $7.59 |
| Tuna Melt | $8.19 |
| Chicken Salad | $8.19 |
| Egg Salad | $7.59 |
| Cheese Melt | $3.99 |
| Pizza Bagel | $5.99 |
| Veggie Delight – lettuce, tomato, cukes, onion, alfalfa sprouts, deli mustard | $5.49 |
| Hummus | $6.99 |
| * Extra slice of cheese | $0.60 |
| * On asiago or wheatberry | $0.60 |
Deli Favorites
Any deli sandwich made on your choice of bagel, wheat wrap, NY rye, asiago*, wheatberry bread* with your choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts
| Roasted Turkey Breast | $7.59 |
| Sahlen’s Ham | $7.59 |
| Roast Beef | $8.99 |
| BLT | $6.99 |
Salads
| Whitefish Salad | $9.99 |
| Cream Cheese & Nova | $12.99 |
| Greek or Caesar Salad | $6.99 |
| Green Salad with Tuna | $9.49 |
| Chicken Caesar Salad | $9.49 |
| Classic Salad Plate – choice of 2 scoops of our classic salads – tuna, egg or chicken, with lettuce, tomato, cukes and bagel chips | $9.99 |
Taste Tempting Specialties
| The Delaware Roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing |
$9.49 |
| The Buffalo Club Roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise |
$9.49 |
| Albuquerque Turkey Roasted turkey, a shmear of red pepper jalapeno, lettuce and tomato |
$9.49 |
| Athens Turkey Turkey breast, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato and special dressing |
$9.49 |
| Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular Our classic tuna, provolone cheese, sliced black olives, special dressing, lettuce and tomato |
$9.49 |
| Hummus Wrap Spectacular Hummus, feta, black olives, red onion and special dressing |
$9.49 |
| The Snyderr Sahlen’s ham with scallion schmear, lettuce and tomato |
$9.49 |
| The Reuben Hot corned beef or roasted turkey, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing |
$10.99 |
| The Hopkins Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing |
$10.99 |
| The Downtowner Rare roast beef, red onion, hot banana peppers and a shmear of garlic & herb |
$9.99 |
| Athens Chicken Marinated chicken, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato and special dressing |
$9.99 |
| Chicken Club Wrap Wheat wrap with marinated chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing |
$9.99 |
| Chicken Caesar Wrap Marinated chicken breast, asiago cheese, lettuce, tomato & Caesar dressing |
$9.99 |
| The Hertel Turkey, ham, pepperoni, melted provolone, tomato, banana pepper and special dressing |
$9.99 |
| Add a regular Pepsi and a bag of chips | $3.49 |
| Add a regular Pepsi and a side of coleslaw or potato salad | $3.99 |
| Add a regular Pepsi and regular soup | $4.49 |
Soup of the Day
| Regular | $3.99 |
| Large | $4.69 |
| Chili – Regular (in season) | $5.99 |
| Chili – Large (in season) | $6.99 |
| Chilli – Regular w/buttered bagel (in season) | $6.99 |
Side Orders
| Chips or Pretzels | $1.75 |
| Potato Salad or Coleslaw | $2.39 |
Desserts
| Cookie | $2.39 |
| Chocolate Covered Macaroon | $2.39 |
| Brownie | $3.99 |
| Crumb Cake | $3.39 |
| Pound Cake | $3.99 |
| Black & White Cookie | $3.99 |
Beverages
| Jake’s Java – Our finest dark roast. Regular, decaf, or flavored | $2.59/2.79/2.99 |
| Iced Coffee – Chocolate Bianco, Caramel, or Hazlenut | $3.39/3.89 |
| Hot Chocolate | $2.59/2.79/2.99 |
| Hot Tea – regular or herbal | $2.59 |
| Cappucino – French vanilla or original | $3.09/3.49/3.89 |
| Fountain Beverages – Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Loganberry, Lipton Tea, Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper | $2.49/2.69 |
| Lipton Teas, Dr Brown’s, Gatorade | $3.79 |
| Juices | $3.79 |
| Milk | $1.99 |
| Aquafina Water | $2.19 |
Java To Go Box
| Includes cream, sugar, stirrers and cups | $22.99 |
Prices and products subject to change. All products may not be available at all locations.
Bagel Care
A Guide to Storing and Re-heating Bagels
Bagels that you wish to store should be placed in a plastic bag, wrapped tight and put into a freezer as soon as possible.
Convection Oven Method
Preheat oven to 360. Place bagels directly on middle oven rack. Heat for 8 minutes.
Standard Oven Method
Pre-heat oven to 360. Place bagels directly on middle oven rack. Heat for 10 minutes.
MICROWAVING OUR BAGELS IS NOT RECOMMENDED